Arrow 509 Review

Arrow 509 Review – Pain and a Shocking Return in “What We Leave Behind”

Every year, Arrow shocks us with a big mid-season finale. This year was no different! I was left at the end of this episode audibly exclaiming, “What? What? WHAT?” It was a pretty big twist, after all, but my dismay was fueled by both shock and outrage. Why? Well, I think it’s easier to just jump into the recap. You know the drill by now.

Madcap Recap

  1. LAUREL F******* LANCE IS BACK. After all the commotion around killing her off. F******* typical, Arrow.
  2. Evelyn Shaw, you cunning, evil, little traitor. How can you give the team Christmas presents when you sold them all out to Prometheus?
  3. Leave Curtis alone! He’s too good for this suffering of the heart and body!
  4. The flashbacks aren’t Bratva related, but that’s OK because it’s more fun to watch Oliver be haunted by the ghost archer of Christmas past.
  5. Any minute now Prometheus is going to tell Oliver, “Hello, my name is Inigo Montoya Claybourne Junior. You killed my father, prepare to die.
  6. Oliver killed Felicity’s boy toy. Things in the Arrow Cave are going to be AWKWARD.
  7. Diggle was tricked and now he’s in a world of trouble! Leave Digg alone, too!
  8. Evelyn is MIA, and she better stay that way. B*tch is cold, but her reception back a the Arrow Cave would be colder.
  9. I’ll say it again. LAUREL F******* LANCE IS BACK.
Arrow 509 Review

Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen/The Green Arrow [Source: The CW Network, LLC]

Laurel 2.0 – Better, Faster, Laurel-er?

How is Laurel Lance back? Good question. I have mixed feelings on seeing her in the present, and I can’t even be sure if she’s actually there or some figment of Oliver’s imagination. It wouldn’t be the first time he hallucinated her! Laurel’s departure from the show was met with strong emotions from everyone (both for and against her) and, for what it’s worth, her tribute episode was better than I expected. But having Laurel return seems to dishonor that a little. Laurel’s death was understood to be permanent. We’d already been told the magic hot tub was gone. Death would have meaning again. But, surprise, surprise, a superhero show can’t seem to keep a character dead.

So here are some speculations on Laurel’s unexpected return:

  1. It’s not really her. Either she’s a hallucination, a hologram, or a life-like robot that the techies made (you laugh, but then you remember last season’s finale).
  2. She’s real and the Lazarus Pit is working again (more Pit-sickness subplot, oh boy).
  3. She’s real and was resurrected by something other than the Pit (magic, super-science, etc.)
  4. She’s from another Earth. This is a shared-universe show, and we did meet Black Siren on The Flash. So . . . maybe?
  5. She’s displaced from the past (see reasoning for previous speculation).


If I’m being honest, none of these sound like a justified reason to have Laurel return. As I’ve said in previous reviews, I was disappointed with Laurel’s general treatment as an Arrow character. She deserved better. Is this the better that Arrow is trying to give her? I’m a bit worried it’ll make things worse. But I think we can agree that the shock value paid off for this cliffhanger.

Arrow 509 Review

Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen and David Ramsey as John Diggle [Source: The CW Network, LLC]

Billy’s Death and Olicity

The second biggest shock of the episode was watching Oliver unknowingly kill Felicity’s boyfriend. Prometheus is indeed clever and managed to outsmart our broody hero, giving him something new to angst about. It was extremely hard to watch the scene of him back at the Arrow Cave, admitting that he murdered his ex-fiancée’s boyfriend. We have to take a moment to let that sink in. Oliver killed Felicity’s beau, a man she very nearly admitted to loving at the holiday party. His guilt will linger for a long, long time, and it will have heavy repercussions on his relationship with Felicity.

Even though Felicity said she blamed Prometheus for Billy’s death, there will be a part of her that blames Oliver; a part of her that will probably never forgive him. I know that many people are still rooting for Oliver and Felicity to get together in the end, and maybe they will. But having to come back from something like this . . . I don’t know if they can. For the foreseeable future, I think they’ll have to live with an aching chasm between them.

Arrow 509 Review

Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen/The Green Arrow and David Ramsey as John Diggle/Spartan [Source: The CW Network, LLC]

Character Study: Prometheus

First things first: How did Prometheus know how to stage the entire scene from when Oliver killed his father (and the other men)? Did he have access to the security footage and the police evidence? I guess when you have four years to plot your revenge, you go all out on the plan.

And that’s a big part of what defines Prometheus: he’s been on a mission to honor his father for years and focused on, probably, little to nothing else. In that way, he’s a lot like Oliver (who also started out on his mission to honor his father). If Oliver hadn’t let a team of good people build up around him, maybe he would have ended up just like Prometheus: determined to kill and make those who wronged him suffer.

I was hesitant to see Prometheus as a good villain before, but I’m changing my mind on that because his involvement in the plot has allowed the show to bring back nods and characters from the early days of Arrow. This alone has been good for the show, and Prometheus is making Oliver feel the repercussions of his Hood days (more so than he has in previous seasons). That is in line with how gritty and angst-ridden this show is, and that’s not a bad thing. Fans of this show want that again, and it makes Prometheus stand out despite him being another archery-based baddie.

Arrow 509 Review

David Ramsey as John Diggle/Spartan, Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen/The Green Arrow and Rick Gonzalez as Rene Ramirez/Wild Dog [Source: The CW Network, LLC}

Final Thoughts and Quotes

This was a gut-wrenching, surprise-filled episode with high stakes and good pacing. If there’s one thing Arrow does right, it seems to be mid-season finales. And in the wake of last week’s super emotional 100th episode, this show sure seems to be on a roll lately. I hope it can keep it up because I’m thoroughly enjoying it (even if the emotional toll is hard to take). I’m incredibly intrigued on what they plan to do with Laurel’s return, as well as how the team will manage in the wake of Billy’s death and Evelyn’s betrayal. What did you think of the episode? Share your thoughts in the comments and enjoy some quotes from “What We Leave Behind”.

Oliver: “Why?”
Artemis: “Because you’re a fraud. This city needs to be saved FROM you.”

Thea: “I thought we decided not to talk about aliens.”

Felicity: “I can’t believe this is happening.”
Billy: “Can’t you? You think I haven’t noticed that the tall guy in the black mask rollin’ with the Green Arrow was Curtis?”

Rory: “Were you even listening to the rules?”
Rene: “I don’t like listening. Or rules.”

Prometheus: “You haven’t been listening. I’m not going to kill him. I’m going to make him wish he was dead.”

Thea: “There are two types of every legacy; two version of what we leave behind. There’s the good and the bad. You just really have a focus on the really bad.”

Prometheus to Oliver: “You’re not a hero; you’re a killer, and I’m going to show you that. I’m going to show how everything you touch dies.”

Felicity: “Where is Billy?”
Oliver: “I killed Billy.”

Like what you see so far? Follow @ThreeIfBySpace or me, @alishabmarie on Twitter to keep the discussion going. Subscribe to the blog so that you are always on top of The Flash news, as well as your other favorite genre series!


Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
0 items Cart
My account